How to write a peer reviewed article

How to write a peer reviewed article

How to perform a peer review. You’ve received or accepted an invitation to review an article. Now the work begins. Here are some guidelines and a step by step guide to help you conduct your peer review. Visit The Wiley Reviewer Academy to take our free peer review training course Use an outline for your reviewer report so it’s easy for the editors and author to follow. This will also help you keep your comments organized. Think about structuring your review like an inverted pyramid. Put the most important information at the top, followed by details and examples in the center, and any additional points at the very bottom Academic Peer Reviewed Journal Articles - Reviews (review articles and book reviews) | Academic Writing in English, Lund University. Picture: Severin. And if you need to access Academic lot of papers then the cost quickly adds up. Of course you could stick to open access journals i. If unable Review get Article to an article you can create a

How to Perform a Peer Review | Wiley

Last Updated: October 30, References Approved. This article was co-authored by our trained team of editors and researchers who validated it for accuracy and comprehensiveness. wikiHow's Content How to write a peer reviewed article Team carefully monitors the work from our editorial staff to ensure that each article is backed by trusted research and meets our high quality standards.

There are 27 references cited in this article, which can be found at the bottom of the page. wikiHow marks an article as reader-approved once it receives enough positive feedback. This article has been viewed 40, times. Learn more The peer review process is crucial in academic publishing. As a reviewer, you will objectively read the manuscript and provide your expert opinion about whether it is appropriate for publication. You will also identify strengths and weaknesses, which should help the author revise the paper to make it even stronger.

Although you are not a copyeditor, you might still point out writing errors or how the manuscript should be reorganized. Log in Social login does not work in incognito and private browsers. Please log in with your username or email how to write a peer reviewed article continue. wikiHow Account. No account yet? Create an account. Community Dashboard Write an Article Request a New Article More Ideas Edit this Article.

Home Random Browse Articles Courses About wikiHow Easy Ways to Help Approve Questions Review Tech Feedback Fix Spelling Quiz App More Things to Try We use cookies to make wikiHow great.

By using our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Cookie Settings. wikiHow is where trusted research and expert knowledge come together. Learn why people trust wikiHow. Categories Education and Communications College University and Postgraduate Academic Writing Academic Journals How to Write a Peer Review Report.

Download Article Explore this Article parts. Related Articles. Co-authored by wikiHow Staff Last Updated: October 30, how to write a peer reviewed article, References Approved. Part 1 of Determine whether to accept an invitation to review. When a publisher reaches out to you, you should only accept an assignment if it is appropriate.

Analyze the following to make sure you are an appropriate reviewer: [1] X Research source Do you have the required expertise? You need to understand the subject matter well enough to analyze whether the author has made an original and meaningful contribution to the field.

If you can't accept the article, ideally you will recommend a reviewer with sufficient expertise. Do you have the time? There's no reason to accept an assignment if you can't complete it by the deadline given.

Is there a conflict of interest? There are many kinds of conflicts. A conflict exists when you are collaborating with an author of the paper. A conflict also exists if you are friends or a direct competitor of an author. Your journal or publisher should have specific conflict of interest rules. Read with a pen. Once you get the manuscript, you should take out a pen. Underline any sections that seem important and correct mistakes as you are reading. If you have a question, write it down in the margin of the manuscript.

Analyze the originality of the manuscript. A manuscript should make an original contribution to the field. Analyze whether the contribution is significant or only incremental. Determine whether the research would interest other researchers in the field.

No matter how original the research, remember that it must fit the general scope of the publisher. For example, a journal may focus on eighteenth century British literature.

If the article focuses more on nineteenth century visual culture, it might not be appropriate. Ask yourself whether the argument convinced you. A solid manuscript should lay out a problem or question and answer it. You must assess how convinced you are by how to write a peer reviewed article answer. Did you find it compelling? Drill down and assess the following: [5] X Research source Does the data properly support the thesis?

Would additional data make the argument stronger? Is the argument free of obvious errors? Were there mathematical errors made when computing data?

Were the techniques or methods appropriate for the field? Could you recommend different ones? Was important information missing from the paper? If it was supplied, do you think the argument would be stronger? Has the author synthesized the current literature properly? Assess the quality of the writing. A manuscript should be properly written. A poorly written manuscript can impede understanding of the argument and may exhaust the reader's patience.

Note the following as you read: [7] X Research source Can you understand the English? Some authors might have English as a second language. In certain scientific fields, this is common. Is the tone appropriate for the publisher? Does the manuscript need a good copyedit?

Analyze references. The manuscript should come with a list of references. As you read, you should note the works being cited. However, take out the list of references and give how to write a peer reviewed article close scrutiny.

Ask the following: Are there too many references or not enough for the publisher? Some journals might set limits. Is there a work the author has neglected to cite? Is the citation format accurate and standard for the field? For some journals, you may need to check the formatting of citations. Part 2 of Look at the publisher's guidelines. Many publishers offer guidelines on how your peer review report should be structured.

Be sure to follow any guidelines given or available on the publisher's website. Summarize the article in a few sentences. You might want to summarize the how to write a peer reviewed article immediately after reading it or wait a day.

Perhaps the argument is internally inconsistent, or the author is a poor writer who cannot make points clearly or logically. Provide an overview of the manuscript's importance.

You should follow with a high-level summary of the article. Summarize your overall impressions with the work. For example, how to write a peer reviewed article, you should mention the following: [14] X Research source Is the main question interesting and important? How large of an advance in the field does the manuscript make? Is the conclusion well-supported with data? Identify flaws in the argument, how to write a peer reviewed article. Some manuscripts are fatally flawed.

For example, the author's evidence might prove the opposite of the thesis. Alternately, the author might use a method that is no longer considered credible.

13 Tips for Writing a Great Journal Article

, time: 5:01

How to Write a Peer Review Report (with Pictures) - wikiHow

Jun 20,  · Review your own report. Set aside your peer review report and let it sit for a day or two. You will have fresh eyes when you come back to it. Make sure to do the following before submitting: Develop any thoughts that are skeletal or not well-supported. Provide as many specifics from the manuscript as possible. Clarify your argument. Proofread%(55) Articles rГ©cents; Top 5 des Valeurs prГ©fГ©rГ©es et dГ©testГ©es. Comment dГ©couvrir votre devise inspirante? Jeux Infinis: vers une autre conception de la vie. l’Intrapreneuriat est-il l’avenir du salariat? Pourquoi l’innovation des grandes entreprises est difficile? How to perform a peer review. You’ve received or accepted an invitation to review an article. Now the work begins. Here are some guidelines and a step by step guide to help you conduct your peer review. Visit The Wiley Reviewer Academy to take our free peer review training course