Follow the golden rule: Write the type of review you’d want to receive if you were the author. Even if you decide not to identify yourself in the review, you should write comments that you would be comfortable signing your name to. In your comments, use phrases like “ the authors’ discussion of X” instead of “ your discussion of X.” The easiest way to find a peer-reviewed article is by using one of the Library's A scholarly, multidisciplinary database providing indexing and. Scholarly information is based on research is considered reliable information and is suitable for academic writing. Peer-reviewed, or refereed journal articles. Write Journal Article - What is peer review? Writing a peer review for a journal publication is a very important blogger.com journal referring to you for peer review requests your expertise to judge if a review article meets the academic standards for blogger.comr, peer review is not like evaluating a submission by a student under you. Every reviewer needs to balance the perspective of the author of the publication along with the
How to Review a Journal Article: 13 Steps (with Pictures)
PhD2Published has several informative posts about writing journal articles, and more recently has featured a post outlining a potentially revolutionary collaborative peer review process for this kind of publishing. Todays post offers an alternative perspective; that of the journal article peer reviewer. Doing peer reviews provides important experience for those writing their own papers and may help writers consider what they should include based on what peer reviewers are looking for.
At some point in your scholarly career, you likely will get asked to review an article for a journal. In this post, I explain how I usually go about doing a peer review. I imagine that each scholar has their own way of doing this, but it might be helpful to talk openly about this task, which we generally complete in isolation. Step One: Accept the invitation to peer review. The first step in reviewing a journal article is to accept the invitation. When deciding whether or not to accept, take into consideration three things: 1 Do you have time to do the review by the deadline?
Once you accept the invitation, set aside some time in your schedule to read the article and write the review. Step Two: Read the article. I usually read the article with a pen in hand so that I can write my thoughts in the margins as I read. As I read, I underline parts of the article that seem important, write down any questions I have, and correct any mistakes I notice.
Step Three: Write a brief summary of the article and its contribution. When I am doing a peer review, I sometimes do it all in one sitting — which will take me about two hours — or I read it one day and write it the next.
Often, I prefer to do the latter to give myself some time to think about the article and to process my thoughts. When writing a draft of the review, the first thing I do is summarize the article as best I can in three to four sentences. If I think favorably of the article and believe it should be published, I often will write a longer summary, and highlight the strengths of the article. Your critique and accolades may help convince the editor of the importance of the article.
As you write up this summary, take into consideration the suitability of the article for the journal. If you are reviewing for the top journal in your field, for example, an article simply being factually correct and having a sound analysis is not enough for it to be published in that journal.
Instead, it would need to change the way we think about some aspect of your field. Step Four: Write out your major criticisms of the article. When doing a peer review, I usually begin with the larger issues and end with minutiae. Here are some major areas of criticism to consider:.
Step Five: Write out any minor criticisms how to write a peer review for an academic journal the article. Step Six: Review. Go over your review and make sure that it makes sense and that you are communicating your critiques and suggestions in as helpful a way as possible. Finally, how to write a peer review for an academic journal, I will say that, when writing a review, be mindful that you are critiquing the article in question — not the author.
Thus, how to write a peer review for an academic journal, make sure your critiques are constructive. So, in addition to being nice, it is in your best interest. Tanya Golash-Boza is Associate Professor of Sociology and American Studies at the University of Kansas. She Tweets as tanyagolashboza and has her own website. gym said on August 5, Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Extremely helpful information particularly the last part : I care for such info a lot.
I was looking for this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck. Check out my website to get more info about bodybuilding, if you like. Dr subodh kumar said on March 8, Dr Tulsi said on August 23, This article sounds to be extremely helpful to people like me who are learning to peer review. Thanks for this valuable sharing and all the guidelines you provided. Dr Jess said on February 5, just what I needed to get started peer reviewing, and a great approach for achieving consistency.
Thank you ��. Sarah said on March 18, Dr JB said on April 10, Thank you, I have how to write a peer review for an academic journal been invited to write my first review since completing my PhD, and this is what I need to get me started — thanks again.
lisa said on September 24, Mel said on October 2, Melissa said on April 12, Al said on May 7, Ben said on June 16, Adesanmi Adedotun said on June 18, Going through this article is as well like reviewing the whole of the article, because the concept has to be understood otherwise, the key point of the article might not be digestive, however, I sincerely need to have a copy of this, read over it often to fine tune my understanding on how to review an article and perhaps become a good article reviewer to as well help me in my own area of specialization, how to write a peer review for an academic journal.
djlovepossum said on July 3, Your email address will not be published. PhD2Published shared a link. Do Your Students Take Good Notes? See More See Less. Back Up Your Files Now — ProfHacker - Blogs - The Chronicle of Higher Education.
How to Write a Peer Review for an Academic Journal: Six Steps from Start to Finish by How to write a peer review for an academic journal Golash-Boza. Academic PracticeJournal Article Peer ReviewJournal ArticlesNetworking. Related posts: Blind Spots: Using Collaborative Open Peer Review to Support PGR Publishing. Thank you for the great post. I am writing my first review and this is very helpful.
Thanks it is very helpful especially for new reviewer like me ��. Thank you for the informative article, it is very helpful to someone new to peer reviewing! Leave a reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Please leave these two fields as-is:. To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math so we know that you are a human Academic Writing Month AcWriMo. TOOLKITS LEADER BOARD LATEST ABOUT. Recent Posts. AcWriMo is All Yours!
Transitions: Reimagining your academic output by embracing a mind-set of abundance by Christopher Hill How to write a peer review for an academic journal Transforming your students writing with feedback for future work by Christopher Hill Transitioning Fields: Turning and facing the strange of a new academic specialization by Christopher Hill Transitioning Abroad? Insight on Working Overseas from an Academic Rolling Stone. By Christopher Hill. Academic Writing Month.
View on Facebook. View on Facebook · Share. PhD2Published 5 years ago. Back Up Your Files Now — ProfHacker - Blogs - The Chronicle of Higher Education www.
How to Write Effective Peer Review Comments
, time: 4:51How to peer review: practical templates, examples, and free courses
The easiest way to find a peer-reviewed article is by using one of the Library's A scholarly, multidisciplinary database providing indexing and. Scholarly information is based on research is considered reliable information and is suitable for academic writing. Peer-reviewed, or refereed journal articles. Write Journal Article - What is peer review? How To Write Review Of An Article - Academic Journals - peer review. Bookmark Page Academic We're online. When you are required to write a Review review, Article will need to do Academic main things: summarise and evaluate a text. The critical review can be of a book, a chapter or Review journal Writing a peer review for a journal publication is a very important blogger.com journal referring to you for peer review requests your expertise to judge if a review article meets the academic standards for blogger.comr, peer review is not like evaluating a submission by a student under you. Every reviewer needs to balance the perspective of the author of the publication along with the
No comments:
Post a Comment