How to peer review Peer review is designed to assess the validity, quality and originality of articles for publication. Reviewers play an essential role in validating the research submitted and providing constructive feedback to the editors and authors Follow the golden rule: Write the type of review you’d want to receive if you were the author. Even if you decide not to identify yourself in the review, you should write comments that you would be comfortable signing your name to. In your comments, use phrases like “ the authors’ discussion of X” instead of “ your discussion of X.” Nov 17, · How to Write a Peer Review: 12 things you need to know 17 November on Peer Review, How to peer review, Review Template, Peer review tips, Peer review example. Learning how to peer review is no small feat. You’re responsible for protecting the public from false findings and research flaws, while at the same time helping to uncover legitimate breakthroughs
How To Write a Peer Review: 12 Things You Need To Know
Learning to write a constructive peer review is an essential step in helping to safeguard the quality and integrity of published literature. Read on for a bunch of resources that will get you on the right track, including peer review templates, example reports, and how to write a peer review paper Publons Academy: our free, online course that teaches you the core competencies of peer review through practical experience try it today.
Understanding the principles, forms and functions of peer review will enable you to write solid, actionable review reports. It will form the basis for a comprehensive, well-structured review, in which you can comment on the quality, rigour, and significance of the research paper, and can identify potential breaches of normal ethical practice. Peer reviewers and editors are gatekeepers of the research literature used to document and communicate human discovery.
Reviewers therefore need a sound understanding of their role and obligations to ensure the integrity of this process, to help maintain quality research, and to help protect the public from flawed and misleading research findings. Learning to peer review is also an important step in improving your own professional development. We strongly encourage you to learn the core concepts of peer review by joining a course or workshop. You can attend in-person workshops to learn from and network with experienced reviewers and editors.
As an example, Sense about Science offers peer review workshops every year, how to write a peer review paper. To learn more about what might be in store at one of these, researcher Laura Chatland shares her experience at the workshop in London, how to write a peer review paper.
There are also plenty of free, online courses around, including the Publons Academy. The Publons Academy teaches you the core competencies of peer review through practical experience. You will learn all the core concepts of peer review, and then straight away start writing real how to write a peer review paper of preprints or published papers with guidance from your mentor. Peer review templates are helpful to use as you work your way through a manuscript.
It offers points to consider for all aspects of the manuscript, how to write a peer review paper, including the abstract, methods, and results sections. It also teaches you how to structure your review and will get you thinking about the overall strengths and impact of the paper at hand.
If no such formal approach exists, try asking the editor for examples of other reviews performed for the journal, which will give you a solid understanding of what they expect from you. Some of these are transparent peer reviewswhich means the entire process is open and visible — from initial review and response through to revision and final publication decision.
F has also put together a nice list of expert reviewer comments pertaining to the various aspects of a review report. Co-reviewing sharing peer review assignments with senior researchers is one of the best ways to learn peer review as it gives researchers a hands-on, practical understanding of the process. In a recent article in The Scientistthe team at Future of Research argues that co-reviewing can be a valuable learning experience for peer review, as long as it's done properly and with transparency.
If you are asked to write a peer review on behalf of a senior colleague or researcher, make sure you get recognition for your efforts by using our collaborative reviewer feature. The Publons Academy is uniquely practical in this sense. The course requires students to gain experience in peer review by practicing the skill on real papers, and by working with their supervisor for feedback.
Upon completion of the course, the supervisor will endorse the student, who will then be put in front of top editors in their field. Check out some of our top picks:. Want to learn more? Become a master of peer review and connect with top journal editors as a graduate of the Publons Academy -- your free online course designed by expert reviewers, editors and Nobel Prize winners.
Enrol today. Menu Close Home Subscribe. How to write a peer review Understanding the principles, how to write a peer review paper, forms and functions of peer review will enable you to write solid, actionable review reports. Why learn to peer review? Peer How to write a peer review paper Templates Peer review templates are helpful to use as you work your way through a manuscript.
Peer review examples Understand what a constructive peer review looks like by learning from the experts. Pre-publication peer review: Patterns and mechanisms in instances of endosymbiont-induced parthenogenesis Pre-publication peer review: Can Ciprofloxacin be Used for Precision Treatment of Gonorrhea in Public STD Clinics?
Co-reviewing Co-reviewing sharing peer review assignments with senior researchers is one of the best ways to learn peer review as it gives researchers a hands-on, practical understanding of the process.
Other peer review resources, blogs, and guidelines Here are some external peer review resources found around the web: Peer Review Resources from Sense about Science Peer Review: The Nuts and Bolts by Sense about Science How to review journal manuscripts by R.
Check out some of our top picks: How to Write a Peer Review: 12 things you need to know Want To Peer Review? Enrol today Publons allows you to record, verify, and showcase your peer review contributions in a format you can include in job and funding applications without breaking reviewer anonymity.
Register now to start building your verified peer review record.
Sample Peer Review
, time: 10:01How to Write a Peer Review - PLOS
3. Write a clear and constructive review. Comments are mandatory for a peer review. The best way to structure your review is to: Open your review with the most important comments—a summarization of the research and your impression of the research. Make sure to include feedback on the strengths, as well as the weaknesses, of the manuscript Follow the golden rule: Write the type of review you’d want to receive if you were the author. Even if you decide not to identify yourself in the review, you should write comments that you would be comfortable signing your name to. In your comments, use phrases like “ the authors’ discussion of X” instead of “ your discussion of X.” How to peer review Peer review is designed to assess the validity, quality and originality of articles for publication. Reviewers play an essential role in validating the research submitted and providing constructive feedback to the editors and authors
No comments:
Post a Comment